[24] It was shared by Conservative Party politician David Davis, who called it "excellent" and said that it was "disentangling the statistics",[5] while American comedian Jimmy Dore used it to claim that COVID-19 deaths had been over-reported and that the figures proved that the public had been victims of a "scaremongering campaign". Campbell contrasted the rate of adverse events for these two vaccines with the higher one cited for COVID-19 vaccines, expressing puzzlement over why the COVID-19 vaccines are officially promoted while the other two were withdrawn. In short, this is once again a case of comparing apples and oranges. 24 Nov 2021. He also comes out in support of Ireland making its own vaccines. But there is evidence that the abstract is flawed and being misrepresented by others to claim that vaccines cause heart attacks. Oliver called this comparison one of apples and oranges. For example, in the results presented for the protein biomarker changes, Gundry uses symbols such as =/- or +/- without any context or explanation. With the information gathered, one could then extrapolate how the He concluded by saying that the COVID-19 vaccines were officially promoted, in contrast to the other two, adding that Youll be as confused as I am over this state of affairs. In a tweet by Campbell sharing the video, the gist of his video was made more clearly: Serious adverse vaccine events, 1 in 800. Gundrys abstract has been criticized by many for its sloppiness and lack of details. The authors of the abstract refuted such misrepresentations of their paper, with one writing on Twitter, "People like John Campbell are calling this a 'great thought out study' when in reality it's an abstract with preliminary data. single 2 Sep 2021. We've consulted with our team of licensed nutritionists and dietitians to bring you informed recommendations for food products, health aids and nutritional goods to safely and successfully guide you toward making better diet and nutrition choices. Experts fact-check health claims in Netflixs The Goop Lab. Global News. David Spiegelhalter, chair of the Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication at Cambridge University, told Full Fact that the study considered only COVID-19 hospitalization as the basis for measuring benefit from vaccination, and that this was only for two months and at a time when COVID-19 cases were relatively low. Spike protein from the vaccine found in the damaged brain." So for example, on the 8th of May, the Delta variant was 1.2%. Initially, the videos received praise, but they later veered into misinformation. In the authors response to Full Fact regarding this criticism, which can be read in full on Zenodo, they wrote that this had to be done because they didnt have access to individual-level data. In summary, because of the methods used, the study doesnt provide reliable evidence for Campbells suggestion that the risk of vaccine-related adverse events is greater than that of COVID-19. He concluded by saying that the COVID-19 vaccines were officially promoted, in contrast to the other two, adding that Youll be as confused as I am over this state of affairs. [10] Between February and March 2020, his channel increased from an average of 500,000 views per month to 9.6 million, mostly from American viewers. Accessed 13 Dec 2021. Dr John Campbell on a new Pfizer treatment that could stop COVID dead in its tracks. He is a stats and numbers guy, CNN has had him on, and to put it frankly he knows his shite. It is not proof that people should not get vaccines. AHA Challenges Diet Doctors Study Alleging COVID Vax Risks. With the information gathered, one could then extrapolate how the Campbell, T. Colin, and Thomas Campbell. In a 2012 article for the Milbank Quarterly, bioethics expert Jason Schwartz reported that the decision by the ACIP to cease recommending Rotashield in the U.S. ultimately discouraged other countries, including developing nations that faced a greater risk from rotavirus than the U.S., from using the vaccine[5]. A review in Emergency Nurse magazine said that the latter textbook contained "excellent [and] inexpensive notes on the causes, pathophysiological changes, and clinical features seen in disease processes". Campbells suggestion that the rate of adverse events following vaccination alone was the basis for the withdrawal of the two vaccineswhich by extension suggests that these numbers alone serve as a valid measure of vaccine safetyis misleading for viewers. It is therefore expected that administration of a vaccine induces a transient increase in inflammatory mediators in the serum. PULS (Protein Unstable Lesion Signature) Cardiac Test, that its makers say can identify endothelial damage by measuring. We strive to only recommend products that adhere to our philosophy of eating better while still enjoying what you eat. The score are categorized into risk categories: normal, borderline or elevated. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says the benefits of the vaccine outweigh the potential risks of heart inflammation. 03/03/23 9:34 PM EST, Video & Audio Myocarditis and Pericarditis After mRNA COVID-19 Vaccination. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Worse yet Dr. Campbell points out some authorities which recommend against aspiration. Without knowledge of what subset were sampled/not sampled and their demographics, and what procedure was used to select these samples for processing, we cannot rule out the results driven by selection bias.. criticized in the past for using an abstract for a poster presentation as if it contained peer-reviewed, validated findings. 24 Jan 2020. [4] Dr John Campbell. Spike protein from the vaccine found in the damaged brain." Dr. John Campbell, known for his clarity when breaking down the finer points of this pandemic, shared 5 points everyone should read to stay safe. Collie, Meghan. But there is evidence that the abstract is flawed and being misrepresented by others to claim that vaccines cause heart attacks. Myocarditis and Pericarditis After mRNA COVID-19 Vaccination. Lectins: Are These Food-Based Proteins Friend or Foe? Medscape. So presumably if this trend continues, and unfortunately we've no reason to suspect it won't, we would expect the Delta variant by the 7th of July to represent 40% of cases in the United States and 80% in 21st of July. [8] He is the author of the nursing-related bioscience textbooks Campbell's Physiology Notes and Campbell's Pathophysiology Notes. Interview with FactCheck.org. Read onand to ensure your health and the health of others, don't miss these Sure Signs You Have "Long" COVID and May Not Even Know It. ", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_Campbell_(YouTuber)&oldid=1141501921, Pages containing links to subscription-only content, Short description is different from Wikidata, Pages using embedded infobox templates with the title parameter, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 25 February 2023, at 10:55. The study also identified COVID-19 as a possible risk factor for ischemic stroke. What is the science behind The Goop Labs claims? In March 2020, Instagram committed to removing false claims or conspiracy theories that have been flagged by leading global health organizations and local health authorities as having the potential to cause harm to people who believe them.. In brief, the study compared adverse events following COVID-19 vaccination with the risk of COVID-19 hospitalization, in order to estimate the harm-benefit ratio of COVID-19 vaccination. Get the best food tips and diet advice But the returns on that policy are unclear. 6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e, 2 Speakers COVID-19 cardiac injury: Implications for long-term surveillance and outcomes in survivors. Heart Rhythm. 7 3. John Campbell, an academic and A&E (accident and emergency) nurse of 40 years, has achieved viral fame for his YouTube videos addressing the realities of the novel coronavirus. In 2017, his diet was labelled as the latest pseudoscience diet fad and the next gluten.He did not reply to our request for comment. [13] He has two children.[29]. Finally, the included AESIsthe chosen measure of vaccine harmsdont always compare to COVID-19 hospitalization in terms of severity. xhr.send(payload); On February 8, Facebook promised to expand its efforts to remove false claims on Facebook and Instagram about COVID-19 and vaccines" as part of a broader effort to shepherd users toward more reliable information about the pandemic and how and where to get vaccinated. . In her YouTube video about the study, Susan Oliver, a nanomedicine scientist at the University of New South Wales, pointed out that conditions like rash, diarrhea, and arthritis, while defined as AESIs, dont typically require hospitalization. Watson, John. Worse yet Dr. Campbell points out some authorities which recommend against aspiration. He is a stats and numbers guy, CNN has had him on, and to put it frankly he knows his shite. Updated 12 Nov 2021, accessed 10 Dec 2021. In a 2009 interview for the Bulletin of the World Health Organization, Harvey Fineberg, then president of the U.S. Institute of Medicine, stated that these cases of GBS wouldnt have been a blip on the screen had there been a pandemic but, in the absence of any swine flu disease, these rare events were sufficient to end the programme. John Lorimer Campbell is an English YouTuber and retired nurse educator known for his videos about the COVID-19 pandemic. Haigh, Joshua. The adverse events reported for the COVID-19 vaccines, on the other hand, comprised many different adverse events, including diarrhea and arthritis, neither of which are associated with the COVID-19 vaccines. } He also comes out in support of Ireland making its own vaccines. In other words, claims like Campbells draw a false equivalence between the measured vaccine harms and COVID-19 hospitalization. 6 November 2021 Competing interests: AgeofAutism.com, an on-line daily journal, concerns itself with the potential environmental sources for the proliferation of autism, neurological impairment, immune dysfunction and chronic disease. The abstract, which by nature is a brief summary and in this case represented preliminary research that is not peer-reviewed, concludes that mRNA vacs dramatically increase inflammation on the endothelium and T cell infiltration of cardiac muscle and may account for the observations of increased thrombosis, cardiomyopathy, and other vascular events following vaccination. The abstract is not part of a full scientific paper, and was presented as a poster at AHAs Scientific Sessions online program on Nov. 13. "So the way we avoid needing maybe more boosters down the road is to squash this as quickly as possible by getting everyone that vaccine. Finally, these vaccines of questionable safety are being recommended for - perhaps soon to be mandated for - younger and younger age groups Heart-inflammation risk from Pfizer COVID vaccine is very low. Nature. We received them and as part of the back and forth process yet they are not final until accepted/published, she said. In all vaccine RCTs, the harms are frontloaded, while the benefits accrue gradually over time.. Dr. Campbell is strongly of the opinion that aspiration should be used, that the vaccines are currently being administered wrongly, and that an urgent change to the procedure is needed. And of course, this is partly why the Delta variant is doubling in percentage every two weeks in the United States. In short, Dr Campbell may sound as though he is comparing the risk of the Covid vaccine to the risk of Covid itself, but his analysis: includes serious adverse events that the vaccine may not have caused excludes many Covid hospitalisations that may have been more serious than those events According to a press release, as of June, the company had sold 120,000 tests since its launching in 2018. I receive no payment as UK Editor. So that is a pity.it's largely been the Southern states that have been lower in numbers. a list of adverse events of special interest (AESIs), Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication, an estimated 25 to 50 million deaths worldwide, withdrawn less than a year after licensure, According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Serious adverse events of special interest following mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in randomized trials in adults, Safety and Efficacy of the BNT162b2 mRNA Covid-19 Vaccine, Efficacy and Safety of the mRNA-1273 SARS-CoV-2 Vaccine, Rotavirus Vaccination and the Global Burden of Rotavirus Diarrhea Among Children Younger Than 5 Years, The First Rotavirus Vaccine and the Politics of Acceptable Risk. PULS Cardiac Test website. The score are. The number of AESIs were used as a measure of vaccine harm. The Next Gluten. The Atlantic. In a tweet by Campbell sharing the video, the gist of his video was made more clearly: Serious adverse vaccine events, 1 in 800. Emails sent to FactCheck.org 2 Dec 2021, 10 Dec 2021. None of the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines have been linked to thrombosis. Scientists had discovered that the flu virus responsible for the outbreak appeared to be genetically similar to the one that caused the deadly 1918-1920 flu pandemic, which led to an estimated 25 to 50 million deaths worldwide. Therefore, the decision to withdraw the vaccine wasnt solely due to the number of adverse events observed, but also because the risk posed by the disease in this case was so small that the risks of vaccination werent justified by the benefits. 24 Nov 2021. [7], Campbell worked as a nursing educator at the University of Cumbria, and has experience as an emergency department nurse. Vaccination is designed to induce a controlled inflammatory response with the goal of preparing the body to fight the targeted pathogen. Often helmed by chiropractors or osteopaths who use the title Dr. in front of their names, these accounts are spreading dangerous misinformation and avoiding detection on the platform. 38.3% of 18 to 29 year olds with one dose of vaccine. as of Dec. 13, the abstract has been cited in 104,417 tweets by 63,079 Twitter users. Suzanne Grant, a spokesperson for AHA told FactCheck.org the journal has been in communication with Gundry and that it gave him until the evening of Dec. 3 to provide corrections and an updated abstract. 27 Jul 2020. In their wake, a new type of influencer has emerged: micro-influencers. . Circulation. David Spiegelhalter, chair of Cambridge University's Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication, said that such use of the data seemed "entirely inappropriate". What it should be interpreted as is proof that the vaccine works, he told us in an interview. Expression of Concern: Abstract 10712: Mrna COVID Vaccines DramaticallyIncrease Endothelial Inflammatory Markers and ACS Risk as Measured by the PULS Cardiac Test: a Warning. Circulation. Director of the division of biostatistics at the University of Pennsylvania. In the video, Campbell reached back into history to discuss how previous vaccine safety concerns were addressed, citing theadverse events associated with the 1976 swine flu vaccination campaign in the U.S. and the Rotashield vaccine as the cause of both vaccines withdrawal from the market. Dr. Campbell is strongly of the opinion that aspiration should be used, that the vaccines are currently being administered wrongly, and that an urgent change to the procedure is needed. American Heart Association Media Relations. A Project of The Annenberg Public Policy Center, This article is available in both English and Espaol, , primarily in young men, after receipt of the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. Speakers Email sent to FactCheck.org. There is no detail on whether the patients had any other health conditions or previous heart issues. "There are adults in the United States at the momentis 65.6% vaccinated. Dr. In the video, Campbell implies that natural immunity is better than vaccinated immunity, a declaration hed made in a previous post that had been taken down by Instagram. Within a few days, the video had been viewed over 1.5 million times. Outcomes of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Patients Recently Recovered From Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19). JAMA Cardiology. Gorski, David. The publisher later issued an expression of concern about the abstract until a suitable correction can be published.. 2 Dec 2021. Mitrani, Raul D., et al. In short, Dr Campbell may sound as though he is comparing the risk of the Covid vaccine to the risk of Covid itself, but his analysis: includes serious adverse events that the vaccine may not have caused excludes many Covid hospitalisations that may have been more serious than those events In the video, Campbell implies that natural immunity is better than vaccinated immunity, a declaration hed made in a previous post that had been taken down by Instagram. Despite Instagrams recent efforts to tamp down vaccine misinformation, Media Matters found several posts with tens of thousands of interactions featuring false and misleading claims about COVID-19 vaccines. But studies have shown the risk is very low and most people recover quickly. Rare cases of heart inflammation have been reported, primarily in young men, after receipt of the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. Read onand to ensure your health and the health of others, don't miss these, "Rochelle Walensky, the CDC Director, anticipates the Delta variant will become dominant in the next one to two months," said Dr. Campbell. A 2018 study in JAMA Pediatrics estimated that rotavirus caused more than 120,000 deaths in 2016, with more than 80% of these deaths occurring in sub-Saharan Africa[4]. Last summer, the Center for Countering Digital Hate found that Instagram acted on only 10% of the posts researchers had flagged as containing coronavirus misinformation. ", RELATED: First Signs You Have a Serious Illness, 5 He told us the numbers in the abstract are being misused by vaccine opponents. [7] He holds a diploma in nursing from the University of London, a BSc in biology from the Open University, an MSc in health science from the University of Lancaster, and a Ph.D. in nursing from the University of Bolton. Is it worth mentioning that none of the experts reached for this story were familiar with the PULS test, which has been questioned by experts online after Gundrys abstract was published. [9] In 2008, he established a YouTube channel to provide educational lectures on topics in health science and nursing. Some research also suggests that the disease raises the risk of a heart attack and other related cardiovascular events. What it should be interpreted as is proof that the vaccine works, he told us in an interview. The misinformation was embraced by American comedian Jimmy Dore and achieved wide circulation on social media, marking the third time Dore had used a Campbell video to spread COVID-19 misinformation. Update, Dec. 22: On Dec. 21, AHA published several corrections to the abstract, emphasizing that the findings were observational in nature. Multiple peer-reviewed published studies have shown that the benefits of COVID-19 vaccination outweigh its risks. [26] An ONS spokesman said suggesting that the 17,000 figure "represents the real extent of deaths from the virus is both factually incorrect and highly misleading". CUMBRIAN health heavyweights have moved to quell concerns over AstraZenecas Covid vaccine after blood clot fears were raised. According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): The risk of intussusception increased 20 to 30 times over the expected risk for children of this age group within 2 weeks following the first dose of RotaShield vaccine. ", "Incorrect vaccine administration is a potential cause of post-vaccine adverse effects, but more research is still needed to confirm or reject this hypothesis", "Did mutations or ivermectin help stamp out Delta in Japan? The Delta variant, which is more transmissible than any before it, is likely going to become the dominant staring of COVID in America, leaving anyone vulnerable at riskand all of us at risk if it continues to spawn, and develop an even more dangerous mutation. Finally, it later emerged that the vaccine was associated with a slight increase in Guillain-Barr syndrome (GBS), an autoimmune disorder affecting the nerves. Pollard's comments come after UK-based health analyst Dr. John Campbell told DW that omicron is "not likely to completely invalidate the vaccines." Experts fact-check health claims in Netflixs The Goop Lab, Campbell, T. Colin, and Thomas Campbell. Editors note:SciChecks COVID-19/Vaccination Projectis made possible by a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The safety data in the Pfizer trial had a data cut-off date of 9 October 2020, according to the published results of the trial in the New England Journal of Medicine[2], while those of the Moderna vaccine trial had a data cut-off date of 25 November 2020[3]. The abstract says measurements for three of the nine biomarkers IL-16, sFas and HGF increased. [3][4][5] As of January 2023, his YouTube channel had 2.65 million subscribers and over 598 million views. What it should be interpreted as is proof that the vaccine works, he told us in an interview. [13] In March 2020, he argued that China's COVID-19 statistics were grossly underestimated and that the US and UK were doing too little to contain COVID-19. Clarification, Dec. 16: Grant, a spokesperson for the AHA, clarified that Gundry has submitted a corrected abstract, but it has yet to be approved. Another issue is the fact that COVID-19 hospitalizations could only be counted once, in the context of the relatively short duration studied, but AESIs were counted on a per-event basis. [20] Meaghan Kall, the lead COVID-19 epidemiologist at the British Health Security Agency, said that Campbell was confusing causation and correlation and that there was no evidence of ivermectin being used in large numbers in Japan, rather that his claims appeared to be "based on anecdata on social media driving wildly damaging misinformation". "The current vaccine we use will cover about 70% of the Delta variant. The numbers in the abstract, he added, are impossible to understand. The same story can be told with the Rotashield vaccine, which protects against severe rotavirus disease. "We're going to see the Delta variant breaking through in areas of the United States. John Campbell, an academic and A&E (accident and emergency) nurse of 40 years, has achieved viral fame for his YouTube videos addressing the realities of the novel coronavirus. into risk categories: normal, borderline or elevated. Now on the 23rd of June, it's 20.6%. Hes not so sure. The Delta variant is doubling every two weeks, replacing the B 1.1.7 Alpha UK variant. Dr. Campbell is strongly of the opinion that aspiration should be used, that the vaccines are currently being administered wrongly, and that an urgent change to the procedure is needed. Measurements of these biomarkers above the norm create a higher PULS score, and measurements below the norm lowers create a lower score. } 8 Dec 2021. . With the information gathered, one could then extrapolate how the It should not be surprising to anyone that a vaccine temporarily stimulates a transient inflammatory response, which the PULS test is sensitive enough to capture. That includes pages of anti-vaccine entrepreneurs like Del Bigtree and Robert F. Kennedy -- though Kennedy still has access to large audiences via his nonprofit Childrens Health Defense, which has hundreds of thousands of followers on both Facebook and Instagram. [19], In November 2021, Campbell said in a video that ivermectinan antiparasitic drugmight have been responsible for a sudden decline in COVID-19 cases in Japan. Pollard's comments come after UK-based health analyst Dr. John Campbell told DW that omicron is "not likely to completely invalidate the vaccines." Predective Health Diagnostics Company. We strive to explain whether and why information is or is not consistent with the science and to help readers know which news to trust. WebJohn Lorimer Campbell is an English YouTuber and retired nurse educator known for his videos about the COVID-19 pandemic.Initially, the videos received praise, but they later veered into misinformation. In the past month, Instagram has removed some of the most influential anti-vaccine accounts from itsplatform. In todays COVID-19 Update, James Campbell, MD, MS, professor of pediatrics and an infectious diseases specialist with the University of Maryland Medical Center, discusses vaccine developments related to adolescents and children, and the latest teen trials from Pfizer and Moderna. , the director for cardiac immunology in the Johns Hopkins University Division of Cardiology who. Alek Korab is a Co-Founder and Managing Editor of the ETNT Health channel on Eat This, Not That! Email sent to FactCheck.org. Researchers Investigate What COVID-19 Does to the Heart. Even though Campbell doesnt mention the expression of concern, he says hes surprised by the abstract typos, lack of clear data and methodology, and even by the fact that Gundry sells. The true benefit of vaccines extend far beyond this period, so the harm/benefit comparison used in this study seems entirely inappropriatethe trials were not designed to estimate the reduction in severe Covid, he said. Bookmark A British doctor has become an unlikely YouTube star as the coronavirus grips the world. Hundreds of millions of doses of COVID-19 vaccines have now been administered in the U.S. None of the vaccines authorized or approved for use in the U.S. are known to increase the risk of heart attack in any population. It says measurements were taken three to five months before the administration of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and then two to 10 weeks after a second dose. Doctor Makes False Claim About Stillbirths in Canadian Hospitals. He has been criticised for suggesting COVID-19 deaths have been over-counted, repeating false claims about the use of ivermectin as a COVID-19 Morris, Jeffrey S. Director of the division of biostatistics at the University of Pennsylvania. Stiles, Steve. Dr. Campbell Says This Demographic is Vulnerable in the USA Shutterstock Dr. Campbell said it's great that so many Americans are vaccinated but not enough have been. Gundrys preliminary research compared scores from 566 patients, aged 28 to 97, with an equal mix of males and females. . Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The foundation hasno controlover FactCheck.orgs editorial decisions, and the views expressed in our articles do not necessarily reflect the views of the foundation. Benefits from vaccination take longer to appear compared to harms, which usually appear within the first six weeks following vaccination. These changes resulted in an increase of the PULS score from 11% 5 yr ACS risk to 25% 5 yr ACS risk. Gundry has been criticized in the past for using an abstract for a poster presentation as if it contained peer-reviewed, validated findings. , The Plant Paradox by Steven Gundry MD A Commentary. "There are adults in the United States at the momentis 65.6% vaccinated. In the video, Dr. Campbell, who has a doctorate in nursing education but is not a physician, reads the abstract and says that if the findings are correct, it would be incredibly significant. But are they? ", Dr. Campbell said it's great that so many Americans are, "The current vaccine we use will cover about 70% of the Delta variant. At the time of this report, these changes persist for at least 2.5 months post second dose of vac, the abstract reads. But it appears that standard is too narrow. More importantly, the fears over a deadly swine flu pandemic had turned out to be overblown, as there wasnt widespread transmission of the virus in the end. xhr.open('POST', 'https://www.google-analytics.com/collect', true); 4 Jurinske, Casey. Bookmark A British doctor has become an unlikely YouTube star as the coronavirus grips the world. One of which was the perceived safety problems with vaccines. [12] In August 2020, UNICEF's regional office for Europe and Central Asia cited his YouTube channel as an excellent example of how experts might engage with social media to combat misinformation,[16] citing a March 2020 briefing by Social Science in Humanitarian Action. GBS commonly develops after an infection; in fact, getting the flu itself is also associated with an increased risk of GBS. Citing the manner in which previous vaccine safety concernsnamely the swine flu vaccine used in the U.S. in 1976 and the Rotashield vaccinewere handled, Campbell presented the rate of serious adverse events following COVID-19 vaccination reported in a published study, which was higher than the swine flu vaccine and the Rotashield vaccine. Dr. John Campbell, known for his clarity when breaking down the finer points of this pandemic, shared 5 points everyone should read to stay safe. To illustrate how it takes more time for vaccine benefits to become evident compared to vaccine harms, Howard cited a graph in the published study on Pfizers Phase 3 clinical trials[2], showing the cumulative number of COVID-19 cases in the placebo group and the vaccinated group over time.